
After the contracts have been signed an appraisal is one more step in the process of buying a house. If issues arise it typically involves the house appraising for less than the purchase price. If this occurs, there may be some additional negotiation or sometimes the deal may fall apart.
But what happens if the reverse occurs and the appraisal comes in at such an inflated value there is no interest in the property?
The word appraise is defined as “to assess the value or quality”. This can be much different than “market value” which defines what a buyer is willing to pay. In most instances the two are close, in this instance, the two are worlds apart.
A Simplified Short Sale?
A HAFA Short Sale is a process whereby the transaction has been given a set of parameters in advance which should result in a smoother, uncomplicated transaction. The homeowner has been through the loan modification process and very likely has been denied. Therefore the next step is probably to sell the property. You could call it a hybrid transaction. The price and terms are provided in advance. Find a buyer, submit the required documentation and proceed to closing. Saving lots of time and frustration.
Everything is set to run smoothly, unless you are given an appraised value which far exceeds the value of the property based on the poor condition. There is one issue here that remains unknown as to how the value of the property was determined.
Did the Lender Escalate the Appraised Value?
If you consult Occupy Wall Street you might get an affirmative response. Given the fact that the initial sales price is too high and if by a miracle the property were to sell at the inflated price, the short sale may be eliminated because there is no “shortage”, the balance would have been paid in full.
However, in reality the property fails to close within the 120 day listing period, therefore another appraisal is ordered and the new sales price is 5% higher than the one completed 4 months ago. Now we have an equity sale and the homeowner receiving this new found money at closing. According to this progressive thinking, the bull real estate market has returned, therefore you can expect an annual appreciation rate of 15%. Home sellers will be glad to know.
One thing we will never know……did the appraisals truly reflect the professional opinions of the two separate appraisers that conducted and completed licensed appraisals, or was the value actually propped as a disguised attempt to increase the offer price?
You May Pass Go
Finally, through a series of appeals and resubmission of mounds of paperwork (something that a HAFA Short Sale was supposed to eliminate) we were able to close the transaction and save a homeowner from foreclosure.
As for me, maybe next time I will take my chances with the traditional short sale.














What You Have To Say